on May 27, 2014 Opinion

Vimeo Copyright Match, and Choosing The Right Tool for the Job

Subscribe to Email Updates



On May 21st, Vimeo announced on its blog that it will run all uploaded content through a new copyright scanning system which--like YouTube's--will flag any file that contains copyrighted audio. This shocked and dismayed a large portion of its user community, but however disruptive this announcement may have been to many, no one should have been surprised.

The announcement threw the twittersphere into chaos: editors, post supers and freelancers ranted and fumed, their collective noses out of joint. The most frequent complaint was that they could no longer use Vimeo as a client review and approval tool – and they are right.

When working through a rough cut, it’s commonplace to mix temp music for which you don’t have the rights to “set the mood” or to communicate a “wish list” to those negotiating the needle drops. Conversely, if a particular song or video clip is critical to a scene, a content creator may secure the rights to it during pre-production.

Production and post production is highly time sensitive. When clients or execs want to see a cut – they want to see a cut now. No one has time to go through a copyright resolution process (which takes how long? It’s unclear) – even if they do have the rights to use the music.

But everyone who kicked up a fuss was missing the point – Vimeo is not a professional review and approval tool, and never tried to be. 

Don’t get me wrong. Vimeo is a fantastic platform for simple video embedding and for self-distribution of original content. Ever since they announced the Tip Jar and VOD in September 2012, the writing’s been on the wall that they are building a platform for independent content creators to distribute their original work and make money from it.

These are the features of a professional review and approval platform:

  • High quality proxies created automatically at lightning speed

  • Plug-in & App-free accessibility on any device – desktop or mobile

  • Air-tight security with 256-bit encryption and MPAA compliance

  • Timecode-based commenting with NLE-compliant exports

  • Robust reporting and analytics

  • Turn-key branding options & Ad-free links

  • Optional file downloading for distribution use cases

And, if you’re looking for something enterprise-ready:

  • A RESTful API to enable integration & customization

  • Asset management functionality to easily manage your library of finished and work-in-progress assets

  • SSO (Single Sign On) integration capabilities

I understand the vocal frustration with this announcement, but Vimeo is making the right decisions to comply with copyright laws and protect itself from liability as a distribution platform.

To do professional review and approval you need the right tool for the job – something like MediaSilo.

EBook Download: How To Implement DAM For Creative Professionals